Logo AZ - 35 Años entregando soluciones legales

Chile’s AFPs Under Investigation for Losses of USD 7.7 Billion: Fiduciary Duty at the Heart of the Case

Nov 11, 2026

Our senior associate in the Corporate and Business Group, Vicente Martínez, spoke with LexLatin about the investigation into the AFPs following losses in the D and E funds, addressing its legal implications.

A landmark investigation launched by the Chilean regulator against the seven Pension Fund Administrators (AFPs) operating in the country—over losses of $7.7 billion in the D and E pension funds, considered the most conservative in the system—has sparked interest in the fiduciary role these companies must fulfill.

After analyzing the case, legal experts agree that compliance with regulatory standards does not, in and of itself, guarantee the administrators’ fiduciary duty.

“These are two distinct standards, and the second is not exhausted by the first,” emphasizes Mauricio López Lastra, a partner at Lathrop Mujica Herrera y Diez Abogados, who notes that the legal framework—including Decree-Law No. 3,500 and Central Bank regulations—establishes clear limits on investment ranges and eligibility requirements.

Another point is that compliance with these limits is not sufficient on its own, as explained by Vicente Martínez, a senior associate in the corporate and business group at az.

“Article 147 of Decree-Law 3,500 requires investment managers to act to ensure adequate returns and the safety of investments, in the best interests of the funds.”

General Regulation No. 340, dated July 18, 2025, specifies that this duty encompasses diligence and loyalty and that a transaction that appears to be permitted may be incompatible with the fiduciary duty.

Gonzalo Sáez, a partner at the law firm Sáez Abogados, emphasizes that, even if a transaction falls within the legal limits that AFPs have for investing in foreign assets, the fiduciary duty could still be violated:

“This relates to the change in limits regarding derivatives, which, until this month, were determined primarily by amount. As of November 4, that limit will be based on risk, which, in the case of D and E funds, is the strictest,” he adds.

What does the regulation say?

The Chilean system regulates pension fund investments both within and outside Chile at various levels, which the partner at Lathrop Mujica Herrera y Diez Abogados summarizes as follows:

  • The first level is Decree-Law No. 3,500 of 1980, which defines eligible instruments and establishes ranges within which the Central Bank (BC) sets the limits. Thus, in accordance with current regulations, for Fund E, foreign investment may be set between 15% and 35% of the fund, and the BC has set it at the maximum of 35%. The law also limits Fund E’s equity holdings to 5% of the fund. The CB sets the maximum that Fund E may invest in government and Central Bank securities at 80%, within the legal range of 50% to 80%; these figures reflect the legislature’s intent that Fund E is, by design, the lowest-risk fund in the system.
  • The second level is the Pension Fund Investment Regime, which is issued by the Superintendency following a report from the Technical Investment Council and with the approval of the Ministry of Finance. This regime sets forth the technical conditions for each transaction, including limits on unhedged foreign currency—which the law requires it to establish—and the regulation of derivatives.
  • The third level consists of the investment and risk management policies that each pension fund administrator must approve through its board of directors and that the regime itself requires in order to authorize the use of derivatives.

“The law provides that derivatives may be used to hedge financial risks that could affect pension funds or for other purposes, and it delegates to the regulatory framework the definition of the types of transactions and assets permitted, which may be subject to policies, procedures, controls, and other restrictions,” the attorney states.

The regulatory framework authorizes, for investment purposes, currency and interest rate forwards and swaps, and stipulates that exposures to these instruments must be included in the respective investments of each fund for the purpose of applying the corresponding limits.

“An interest rate swap in Fund E does not, in and of itself, constitute a legal violation. Furthermore, until April of this year, there was no limit on the aggregate exposure of the derivatives portfolio; that limit was introduced by Exempt Resolution No. 549, dated April 9,” says López Lastra.

Regarding a fund’s investments, the law establishes that their sole objectives shall be to achieve adequate returns and security, and adds that any other objective shall constitute a serious breach of the management companies’ obligations.

It also requires the AFPs to take all necessary steps to safeguard both objectives, to act exclusively in the best interests of the funds, and to be liable even for slight negligence for any damages they cause, as set forth in General Regulation No. 340, dated July 18, 2025.Rentabilidad de las AFP de Chile

The investigation being conducted by the regulator is based on the premise that the AFPs invested in derivatives (interest rate swaps) in anticipation of a decline in long-term interest rates in the United States, which did not occur.

After conducting audits, the Superintendency of Pensions decided to initiate disciplinary proceedings to determine whether the seven AFPs had breached the duty of loyalty and diligence established in Article 147 of Decree-Law No. 3,500 and the provisions of General Regulation No. 340.

In this context, one of the most relevant points for the legal debate is the nature of the fiduciary duty. The senior associate at az argues that it is a duty of care, not a duty of result, which means that a loss alone does not constitute a breach:

“The question is whether, in deciding on and maintaining the strategy, the AFP diligently assessed its risks, its consistency with the fund’s characteristics, and the available alternatives; whether it monitored and reacted to relevant signals; and whether it adequately documented its decisions. This assessment must be made based on the information available at each moment, not solely in light of the subsequent outcome.”

López Lastra agrees and adds that, according to the regulation, a duty of care—not a duty of result—requires each fund manager to implement and document its decision-making processes, with clear and accessible records that allow for the justification of its decisions.

Consequently, the attorney believes that merely establishing a loss is not sufficient to conclude that negligence occurred. However, the same provision expressly rules out the reverse defense: a breach of duty is deemed to have occurred when the asset manager takes actions that are apparently legitimate—because they are not explicitly prohibited by a rule—but are incompatible with this fiduciary duty. Proving that a transaction complied with regulatory limits is therefore not sufficient to rule out a breach.

“To determine whether or not there is liability arising from the fiduciary duty, one would have to analyze, among other things, the process by which the investment strategy decision was made, and whether it is aligned with the purpose of the respective funds, which are primarily aimed at security and ensuring the payment stream that the fund must provide,” explains Gonzalo Sáez.

In what cases could a legally permissible investment violate the fiduciary duty? The partner at Lathrop Mujica Herrera y Diez Abogados illustrates three situations:

  1. The first is that the assumed exposure is inconsistent with the fund’s risk profile; for example, when a single macroeconomic variable accounts for a substantial portion of its return.
  2. The second is that there are no reasonable mechanisms in place to measure and control the risks associated with the position, including liquidity and collateral risks arising from derivatives.
  3. The third is that significant positions are maintained without sufficient technical justification in the face of significant market changes or warnings from the regulator. NCG No. 340 also considers the duty to be breached if, once a loss has occurred, the fund manager fails to take sufficient action to mitigate or limit the loss.

Mauricio López Lastra emphasizes that this is particularly important in Fund E, which, like Fund D, primarily consists of participants who are close to the legal retirement age—that is, those who have less time to recover from a loss.

“A directional strategy on foreign interest rates must be justified based on that criterion, and not solely on its expected return. I believe that the decisive legal question is not merely whether the investment was authorized, but whether it was adopted, scaled, and supervised with the diligence required of a professional manager of third-party pension funds—a standard that must be assessed based on the information available at the time of each decision,” he states.

What penalties do Chile’s AFPs face?

Capital, Cuprum, Habitat, Modelo, Planvital, Provida, and UNO are the AFPs under investigation in Chile. The law provides for administrative, civil, and criminal penalties.

Among the administrative penalties provided for in Article 17 of DFL No. 101 of 1980 are a reprimand, a fine of up to 15,000 UF (USD 640,000), or up to 30% of the total value of the irregular transactions. For the partner at Lathrop Mujica Herrera y Diez Abogados, this is significant, given a swap portfolio worth billions of dollars.

Revocation of the operating license is another penalty provided for under Chilean law.

“This measure would also require reorganizing the management of the savings of millions of members, so I consider it unlikely,” the attorney opines.

The partner at Sáez points out that the fines go to the government rather than to those affected.

“In civil matters, the AFPs could be ordered to compensate the fund for direct damages if negligent conduct is proven, but first, a breach of the duty of care, actual damage, and a causal link between the two must be established,” explains López Lastra.

There could even be joint and several liability on the part of directors and executives for events resulting from their fault or negligence, as well as on the part of managers, but personal fault must first be established.

The senior associate at az believes that, regardless of whether they could accurately predict the trend in U.S. interest rates, the key issue is whether the directors and managers diligently identified, assessed, and managed the risks they reasonably should have considered.

“NCG 340 requires that decisions be documented and recognizes that the various bodies are accountable within the scope of their respective responsibilities. Therefore, the role of each board, committee, manager, or risk officer should be examined separately: what information they received, what authority they had, what decisions they made, and how they responded to warnings.”

Consequently, he believes that a potential sanction against an AFP does not automatically establish the personal liability of all its directors or managers.

NCG 340 takes effect on July 18, 2025, and, in his view, when evaluating past conduct, one must consider the framework applicable at that time and not simply apply the new requirements retroactively.

His colleague at Lathrop Mujica Herrera y Diez Abogados notes that, in the context of the proceedings, the written reports by Superintendency officials will constitute legal presumptions regarding the facts they personally verified; therefore, the quality and depth of the audit conducted will be decisive in determining the appropriateness of sanctions.

“In my view, the most immediate scenario is the Superintendency’s exercise of its sanctioning powers. However, the most legally significant consequence could be an obligation to compensate for the damages caused to the funds, if it is proven that the losses are attributable to a breach of fiduciary duty. It should be noted that the automatic mechanisms provided for in the Chilean pension system will not apply, since the minimum return and reserve requirements are triggered when a fund manager falls below the industry average, and in this case, all of them fell to a similar extent.”

In fact, a final sanctioning resolution could constitute relevant evidence for subsequent claims for damages, but it would not replace the need to prove the requirements for civil liability, particularly the existence of damage and its amount.

Mitigating Risks Without Destabilizing the Market

Exempt Resolution No. 549, dated April 2026, seeks to strengthen controls over derivatives in pension funds to mitigate risks without triggering forced sales.

López Lastra argues that the central challenge is for the Superintendency of Pensions to effectively oversee compliance with the new liquidity limits and ratios, preventing containment measures from exacerbating the very losses they are intended to mitigate.

This would require asset management firms to submit well-founded risk management plans, approved by their boards of directors and subject to independent audits.

In this regard, he agrees with Martínez that it is crucial to avoid indiscriminate mass liquidations that affect market prices, prioritizing an orderly, documented reduction of positions—in line with prudential criteria—that prevents unnecessary market stress.

The senior associate at az believes that the AFPs should evaluate a combination of gradual position reduction, transactions to offset exposures, strategies such as strengthening liquidity, and strict monitoring of collateral, in addition to reinforcing corporate governance through stress tests and effective controls by the board of directors and the investment committee.

On April 1, 2027, the generational funds established by Law No. 21,735 will take effect, replacing the multi-funds; and in light of recent events, their derivative exposure limits for cohorts nearing retirement should be explicitly reviewed, as López Lastra argues:

“In the meantime, the regulator should clearly inform participants that part of the loss is due to valuation: a massive redemption from Fund E in the midst of a market downturn realizes that loss and forces the sale of assets, with repercussions for the local fixed-income market.”

The attorney argues that protecting the funds requires preventing further excessive exposure, correcting any proven management deficiencies, and assigning responsibility where appropriate, thereby avoiding regulatory decisions that would unnecessarily exacerbate losses.

Beyond the Superintendency of Pensions, expectations are also focused on the Chilean Congress, which is considering several initiatives regarding the financing of compensation by the AFPs for investment losses, including:

a Senate motion penalizing the reckless management of pension funds, introduced on October 21;
and a proposed constitutional amendment requiring the AFPs to reimburse this year’s losses up to the amount of the fees charged, which was introduced in the Chamber of Deputies on October 26 and which raises concerns regarding retroactivity.

Source: LexLatin, November 4. [See here]

Te podría interesar

Laws change overnight. Behaviors don’t

Laws change overnight. Behaviors don’t

We invite you to read the opinion piece by our directors Yoab Bitran (Compliance Group) and Juan Pablo González (New Technologies and AI) on the challenge of integrating data protection into organizational culture. The implementation of new requirements regarding...