Logo AZ - 35 Años entregando soluciones legales

The Legal Industry Reviews 26 No. 2 | Criminal Law: Juvenile Criminal Liability

Nov 16, 2026

Lowering the age of criminal responsibility poses a risk highlighted by the Children’s Ombudsman’s Office: criminal organizations may respond by recruiting even younger children to use them in the commission of crimes.

The involvement of adolescents in violent crimes demands a government response. We cannot ignore the gravity of crimes such as homicide, kidnapping, rape resulting in death, or attacks on police officers or the Gendarmerie. Nor can we ignore the existence of young people whose patterns of recidivism demand effective intervention.

From this perspective, the draft Bill No. 15,589-07 seeks to strengthen the response to particularly serious crimes.

The discussion of this bill has included proposals to lower the age of criminal responsibility from 14 to 13 and to apply the adult system to 16- and 17-year-old adolescents who are repeat offenders or involved in serious crimes. Regarding this latter option, the Executive Branch abandoned the transfer mechanism that would have allowed them to be tried as adults.

The concern is legitimate. However, lowering the age from 14 to 13 does not seem appropriate. Juvenile criminal justice is not a watered-down version of the adult system, but rather a special regime for individuals still in the process of development. These are minors in an early stage of growth, which requires prioritizing preventive measures.

According to the Public Prosecutor’s Office report “Criminal Responsibility of Adolescents in Chile,” the majority of juvenile offenders are 16- and 17-year-olds. Extending the criminal justice system to younger age groups does not address the predominant profile of this phenomenon.

The report also confirms that this is a concentrated phenomenon. Ten percent of offenders account for 43 percent of crimes, while only 2.4 percent of those studied exhibit a persistent pattern of offending and account for 13.4 percent of the offenses. The majority exhibit low-intensity patterns of offending and early desistance.

Lowering the age of criminal responsibility poses a risk highlighted by the Children’s Ombudsman’s Office: criminal organizations may respond by recruiting even younger children to use them in the commission of crimes. This concern is supported by the report from the Public Prosecutor’s Office, which reveals that nearly one in five cases involves the joint participation of adolescents and adults, and that this collaboration has shifted toward crimes associated with organized crime, particularly drug and weapons offenses.

These figures suggest that the state’s response should not focus on expanding punitive measures against children and adolescents, but rather on more rigorously prosecuting those who recruit and exploit them, specifically penalizing such conduct, and strengthening early, targeted prevention efforts addressing risk factors such as dropping out of school, drug use, and access to weapons.

The system’s capacity must also be taken into account. During the discussion of the bill, changes to sentencing guidelines have been proposed that aim to prioritize placement in closed detention facilities and restrict special supervised release for sentences of three years or more.

Regarding the proposal examined at that time, the Office of the Ombudsman for Children, in the Senate Constitution Committee, projected a significant increase in the number of adolescents in custodial settings and reported “that incarceration rates would rise from 209 adolescents to 804 in closed facilities and from 551 to 701 in partial detention.” These estimates must be compared with the text approved by the committee.

If the reform results in greater actual enforcement of custodial sentences without ensuring the necessary infrastructure, specialized staff, and effective programs, this tougher approach may undermine reintegration and, consequently, the public safety it seeks to strengthen.

For more information on these topics, please contact our Criminal Law Group:

Loreto Hoyos | Partner | lhoyos@az.cl

Daniela Castillo | Senior Associate | dcastillo@az.cl

Source: The Legal Industry Reviews, Issue 26, No. 2. [View here]

Te podría interesar

Laws change overnight. Behaviors don’t

Laws change overnight. Behaviors don’t

We invite you to read the opinion piece by our directors Yoab Bitran (Compliance Group) and Juan Pablo González (New Technologies and AI) on the challenge of integrating data protection into organizational culture. The implementation of new requirements regarding...